Shareholders' agreements: 7 clauses every founder should understand
A practical walkthrough of the seven clauses that quietly determine who really controls a company — and what happens when founders disagree.
A shareholders’ agreement is the constitution of a company’s private life. While the Articles of Association are public, the shareholders’ agreement governs how the people behind the company behave towards one another. Drafted well, it prevents disputes. Drafted badly — or not at all — it guarantees them.
1. Pre-emption (right of first refusal)
If a shareholder wants to sell, the others get the first chance to buy at a fair price. This keeps strangers (and competitors) out of the cap table.
2. Tag-along and drag-along rights
- Tag-along protects minority shareholders: if a majority sells, minorities can join the sale on the same terms.
- Drag-along protects majority shareholders: when a buyer wants 100% of the company, the majority can force minorities to sell on the same terms.
These two clauses, together, make the company both safe and sellable.
3. Board composition and appointment rights
Who appoints directors, and how? Founder-led companies often give each founder the right to nominate a director up to a threshold shareholding. Beyond that, appointments are by majority.
4. Reserved matters (veto list)
A list of decisions that require super-majority — or unanimous — consent: issuing new shares, taking on debt above a threshold, selling the business, changing the articles. This is the heart of “control.”
5. Good leaver / bad leaver
What happens to shares when a founder leaves? A good leaver (e.g. retiring, illness) typically sells at fair value. A bad leaver (e.g. breach, competing) sells at a discount. Without this, a departing founder can hold the company to ransom.
6. Non-compete and non-solicitation
For a reasonable period after leaving, a departing shareholder should not set up a competing business or poach staff or customers. Enforceability varies, but a carefully scoped clause is generally upheld.
7. Deadlock and dispute resolution
When two equal founders disagree, who decides? A sensible clause escalates: negotiation → mediation → a casting vote by an independent advisor → buy-sell (“shotgun”) provisions. Without an escalation ladder, companies can stall for years.
A note on drafting
Template shareholders’ agreements are a false economy. The clauses above look simple in the abstract, but their interaction — and the definitions of terms like “fair value”, “competing”, “good leaver” — is where disputes are won or lost.
Bring us your draft, or start from scratch. We will make sure the document matches the relationship.